Smile
Chapter 6: Afterimage
David remained beside the workstation after the studio door closed behind them. The room was quiet again. In the mirror, the place where Jennifer and Rachel had stood was empty. The park image remained open on the monitor beside him.
He switched to the recording from the camera above the styling station.
Jennifer and Rachel stood in the center of the frame exactly as they had entered—Jennifer slightly ahead, Rachel close beside her. He watched the first activation: their heads turning, the locked eye , the moment he stepped forward with the laptop. He advanced to the kiss and let it run. Their mouths stayed fixed while their eyes remained open and panicked. He watched the embrace form, the way their arms rose and their bodies locked together, the long hold before he released them.
It had worked. One source image had controlled both of them. The connection had accepted every composition change while it remained Live. Resistance had altered nothing except the strain around their eyes and the rigidity in their shoulders.
He stopped on the final seconds of the embrace. Rachel’s head had turned slightly farther than the composition required. Jennifer’s shoulder had stayed tense. The overall image looked convincing because a viewer expected the intimacy to be genuine. Closer attention revealed the tension the composition had failed to hide.
Those flaws mattered.
He did not think of what had happened as an assault. The word belonged to crude force. What he had done required precision. The women had remained conscious. Undo had restored them when he chose. Their distress did not invalidate the result. It only showed where the image still needed correction.
He imagined the final portrait: Jennifer and Rachel inside a deliberate frame, bodies aligned, hands placed to imply trust, the same quiet smile held on both faces so neither could contradict it. No fear around the eyes. No visible refusal. The photograph would settle the question they had refused to answer.
He closed the recording and opened the WOMEN archive. He selected a woman he had photographed outside a corporate office three months earlier. Her face was clear, the source image was valid, and he knew where she worked and when she usually left the building.
He left the image in PREVIEW and pressed Print. Paper moved through the tray. The woman appeared gradually—hair, eyes, mouth, shoulders, hand. David watched until the finished print dropped into the tray. He lifted it by the edges and carried it to the proof table.
By then, Rachel and Jennifer were several blocks away.
Rachel drove. Jennifer’s hands had started trembling before they reached the car. She kept them pressed between her knees.
Mara called ten minutes after their message. Rachel answered through the speakers.
“We’re out.”
“Are either of you hurt?”
Jennifer stared through the windshield. “Not in a way anyone can see.”
“Where are you going?”
Rachel glanced toward Jennifer before answering. “My apartment.”
“Stay together. Write everything down. I’m calling the officer.”
Jennifer reached over and ended the call before Mara could ask another question. Rachel did not object.
They did not speak for the rest of the drive.
In the underground garage, Rachel took the camera bag from the back seat, reconsidered, and locked it in the trunk. Jennifer watched her close it. The camera was out of sight. Neither woman felt safer.
They took the stairs. By the second landing Jennifer’s breathing had become uneven. Rachel slowed without asking her to stop.
At the door she unlocked both locks and stepped aside so Jennifer could enter first.
The apartment was smaller than Jennifer expected. The living room and kitchen shared one open space, with photography books filling two shelves and a compact desk holding a closed laptop and a stack of sheets. The framed photographs showed buildings, bridges, and empty streets. There were no portraits.
Rachel closed the door and locked it. She placed the second camera inside a cabinet, covered the laptop camera with a strip of paper, and turned both phones facedown on the kitchen counter. The actions were practical enough that neither woman commented on them.
Jennifer stood near the couch with her arms held close to her body. Her makeup had blurred beneath her eyes. The color around her mouth had faded unevenly.
Rachel rolled one shoulder as though it hurt, then let her arm fall. Her face remained tight and tired.
“You can use the bathroom. There are clean towels under the sink.”
Jennifer walked down the short hall and opened the bathroom door. The mirror faced her directly. She stopped at the threshold without stepping inside.
When she returned to the kitchen, Rachel had filled a bowl with warm water and placed two washcloths beside it.
They sat across from each other. Rachel handed her a cloth without letting their fingers touch. Jennifer cleaned beneath her eyes, then along her cheeks. When she reached her mouth her hand stopped. Rachel lowered her gaze to her own cloth. Jennifer wiped once across her lower lip, then cleaned the corners carefully, as if pressure there might cause something to return.
They moved to the couch and sat at opposite ends. The space between them was wide enough for another person.
Jennifer looked at the closed cabinet. “Tell me exactly what you saw.”
Rachel took a black notebook from the shelf and opened it on the coffee table. At the top of the page, she wrote:
What we know
Several lines below it, she wrote:
What we don’t know
“He used a still from the park video,” Rachel said. “I recognized the background. The program picked us out separately. He changed the picture in Preview, but nothing happened to us.”
“Not until he pressed Change.”
“And looked directly at the picture.”
Jennifer looked down at her hands. “Then it turned red.”
“Live.” Rachel wrote beneath the first heading:
Preview changed only the picture.
Change made our bodies follow it.
“He turned our heads first,” Rachel said. “I think he was checking whether the picture would work on both of us.”
“You saw his face.”
“He was surprised. Only for a second, but he was.”
Jennifer rubbed one thumb across the opposite palm. “Then he changed the picture again without letting us go.”
“The kiss.”
“And the embrace.” Jennifer’s hands closed. “He kept us like that until he was finished looking.”
Rachel’s pen stopped for a moment before she continued writing:
One picture was enough for both of us.He could change the pose while it stayed Live.We stayed awake and knew what was happening.We could fight it, but our bodies still moved.Undo gave us control back.
Jennifer read the last line. “He didn’t give it back.”
Rachel looked at her.
“He stopped taking it.”
Rachel crossed out the final sentence and wrote:
Undo ended his control.
Neither of them spoke for several seconds.
“We don’t know what would have happened if he closed the picture instead,” Jennifer said.
“No.”
Rachel moved to the second heading and wrote:
What happens if he closes it without Undo?
“How many pictures does he have?” Jennifer asked.
“The café photograph worked. The still from the park worked. Anything else he photographed himself might work too.”
“Might?”
“I don’t know enough to say more than that.”
Rachel added:
How many usable pictures does he have?Would a copy or screenshot work?Would deleting the picture stop it?Could someone else operate the program?
Jennifer stared at the list. “What about everyone else in a picture? Someone in the background. A reflection.”
Rachel’s pen hovered above the page.
“I don’t know.”
She wrote:
Who can it pick out inside a picture?
Jennifer watched her add another line.
How many women has he used it on?
By the time Rachel stopped, the second list was longer than the first.
Jennifer leaned back and pressed her palms together. “Everything we planned depended on making him afraid of what we could show people.”
“He is afraid. That’s why he threatened us.”
“That didn’t stop him.”
“No.” Rachel looked at the notebook. “It made him take a bigger risk.”
Jennifer’s voice tightened. “And what stops him from doing it again?”
Rachel looked over the questions, searching for something she had missed.
“I don’t know.”
Jennifer gave a short, strained laugh. “That’s becoming the answer to everything.”
“I know.” Rachel set the pen down. “But I’m not going to pretend we know more than we do.”
The room had grown warm. Rachel opened the window a few inches, letting in the sound of traffic, then returned to the far end of the couch. Jennifer noticed the distance this time. She touched her mouth without meaning to, and Rachel’s eyes followed her hand.
“I know you didn’t choose it,” Jennifer said.
“I know you didn’t either.”
“How?”
“Because I was trying to stop too. I felt you resisting. Your shoulder was rigid. You were pulling away even while your body moved toward me.”
“I felt you too. I knew it wasn’t you, even while it was happening.”
Rachel looked at her for a long moment. Jennifer no longer trusted herself to decide what another person’s expression meant.
“At the summit, I could see people nodding while I spoke,” Jennifer said. “They agreed with what I was saying. Then they saw the smile and thought I was calm. I was terrified, and my face was telling them the opposite.”
“I saw your eyes.”
“In the studio, if someone had photographed us, what would it have shown?”
“Two women kissing. Nothing in the picture would show that we hadn’t chosen it.”
“It would have looked like us.”
“It wouldn’t have been.”
“And most people wouldn’t care,” Jennifer said. “They’d see the picture and think they already knew what happened.”
Jennifer rubbed her palms together. “What happens when what people see is more convincing than what we say happened?”
“We tell the truth.”
“And if they don’t believe it? He could make me smile while I’m accusing him. He could make me look happy while I’m telling someone I’m afraid. He could make me touch you and then show people the picture.”
“I know.”
“Do you?”
Rachel’s face tightened. Jennifer heard how the question sounded only after she had asked it. “I’m sorry.”
“No. You’re asking whether I’ll believe your body or you.”
Jennifer did not deny it.
“I’ll believe you,” Rachel said. “Because I know what it felt like when my body did something I didn’t choose.”
“That happened once.”
“That’s enough.”
Rachel looked down at her hands. “But he didn’t invent what happened before.”
Jennifer’s shoulders stiffened.
“I don’t mean the kiss. I mean the park. I was attracted to you before David. I moved toward you because I wanted to. I stopped because I wasn’t sure what would happen if I kept going. Stopping was real too. So was everything before it.”
“And he used it.”
“He watched it, decided he knew what it meant, and made the rest himself.”
“What he thought should have happened next.”
“Yes.” Rachel looked across the space between them. “He took something unfinished and finished it for us.”
“I don’t want what he did to decide what the park meant.”
“I don’t think it does,” Rachel said. “In the park, I stopped because I wasn’t ready. You let me stop. In the studio, he took that choice away from both of us.”
Jennifer looked at her. “Do you still want to know what would have happened?”
Rachel was quiet for a moment. “I don’t know.”
“Neither do I.”
“Then we don’t decide today. Not because of him, and not just to prove he didn’t take it from us.”
Jennifer nodded slowly. “No. Not today.”
Neither moved closer.
Rachel returned to the notebook after the light outside began to fade. She drew a line beneath the two lists.
“His deadline is six tomorrow,” Jennifer said. “What happens if we do nothing?”
“He could use another picture.”
“He could do that anyway.”
“Yes.”
“What if we delete everything?”
“Then we lose the evidence.”
“He might stop.”
Rachel looked at her. “Do you believe that?”
“No.”
“What if we tell everyone now?”
“We tell the police everything. But putting it online is different. We don’t know what he’ll do if he feels cornered again. He could change you while you’re speaking. He could make us look like we agreed to what happened.”
“So we stay quiet.”
“I didn’t say that.”
“You keep telling me what we can’t do.”
“Because I don’t know what will work.”
Jennifer crossed her arms. “We can’t sit here and wait for six o’clock.”
“I know.”
“Then say something.”
Rachel put the pen down. “I’m trying not to choose the first thing that makes us feel less helpless.”
Jennifer started to answer, then stopped. She had pushed for the warning while Rachel argued for caution. At the summit, Rachel had agreed to the meeting for both of them. Neither wanted fear making another shared decision.
Jennifer looked toward the phones. “You think I’ll make it worse.”
“I think you need to do something right now so he doesn’t get the last word. I understand that. But that doesn’t mean the first thing we do will be the right thing.”
Jennifer remained by the window for a while before returning to the couch.
“I don’t know what to do.”
Rachel had never heard her say it without immediately following with a proposal.
“I don’t either.”
“We need something.”
“Rules,” Rachel said. “Until we know more.”
She picked up the pen and wrote:
DON’T DELETE ANYTHINGDON’T ANSWER HIS DEADLINEDON’T TALK TO HIM ALONEWRITE DOWN EVERYTHING THAT HAPPENEDDON’T POST ANYTHING YETDON’T LET HIM RUSH US
They read the list together. It would not stop David from using another image. It gave them something to follow until they knew more.
Rachel placed the pen beside the notebook. The apartment had darkened around them. She reached toward the lamp and stopped when Jennifer shifted.
“You can turn it on.”
Rachel switched it on, filling the corner with warm light.
Jennifer looked at the space between them. “Can I sit closer?”
Rachel watched her for a moment, then nodded. “Yes.”
Jennifer moved toward the center of the couch but left several inches between them. Rachel rested her hand on the cushion. Jennifer placed hers nearby, close enough that Rachel could feel its warmth.
Rachel turned her palm upward.
Jennifer waited, then placed her fingers against it. Their hands closed lightly around each other.
“We had a plan this morning,” Jennifer said.
“We had rules for getting into his studio and coming back out.”
“What do we have now?”
Rachel looked toward the notebook. “I don’t know.”
They remained on the couch as darkness filled the windows. Their phones stayed facedown on the table.
Nothing had been solved. Neither let go.